keep bananas from turning brown in a banana cream pie?

Introduction to Banana Cream Pie

History of Banana Cream Pie


The banana cream pie, a delightful dessert cherished by many, has a rich history that intertwines with the culinary evolution of pies. Pies, as a concept, have been a part of human cuisine since the time of the ancient Egyptians, but it was not until the 1500s that fruit fillings began to gain popularity. The first recorded instance of a cherry pie, believed to have been made for Queen Elizabeth I, marked the beginning of an era of fruity pies, eventually leading to the creation of the banana cream pie.

Interestingly, the journey of the banana cream pie is relatively recent compared to other pies. Bananas themselves were not a significant part of the American diet until around the 1880s. Their introduction and subsequent rise in popularity paved the way for innovative culinary uses, including their incorporation into pies. The earliest known reference to a banana pie dates back to the Woman’s Exchange Cook Book of 1901, which describes a simple yet delightful recipe involving sliced bananas, powdered sugar, and a pre-baked pie shell, optionally topped with whipped cream.


The 1950s saw the emergence of the banana cream pie as we know it today, filled with luscious custard and topped with fluffy whipped cream. This version quickly became a favorite among American service members and was soon adopted by households across the country. The pie’s popularity crossed the Atlantic, inspiring the British to create their own variant known as Banoffee pie, a delicious combination of bananas and toffee.

The banana cream pie’s journey from a simple recipe in an early 20th-century cookbook to a beloved dessert enjoyed worldwide is a testament to the pie’s versatility and appeal. Its ability to adapt and evolve with changing tastes and culinary trends has cemented its place in the annals of dessert history. As a symbol of culinary creativity, the banana cream pie continues to be a favorite, offering a perfect blend of sweetness, texture, and nostalgia.

The Challenge of Browning Bananas

A common hurdle in making a banana cream pie is the browning of bananas. This natural process, known as enzymatic browning, occurs when bananas are exposed to air. The culprit is an enzyme called polyphenol oxidase, which reacts with oxygen in the air and the polyphenols in bananas, leading to the formation of melanin, the brown pigment. This reaction not only alters the aesthetic appeal of the pie with its unappetizing color but can also affect the texture and taste of the bananas, making them less appealing.

The challenge of browning is more pronounced in banana cream pie due to the pie’s structure. As bananas are sliced and laid out, their increased surface area comes into contact with air, accelerating the browning process. This issue is particularly significant because banana cream pie is often served cold, which means the bananas sit exposed for longer periods, increasing the likelihood of browning.

Addressing this challenge is crucial for both home bakers and professionals, as the visual appeal of a banana cream pie is as important as its taste. The key lies in understanding and mitigating the enzymatic reaction, ensuring that the bananas retain their fresh, yellow appearance for as long as possible, thereby preserving the overall quality and appeal of the pie.

Immediate Preparation

One effective strategy to combat the browning of bananas in a banana cream pie is immediate preparation. This technique involves delaying the slicing of bananas until the last possible moment before assembling the pie. By minimizing the time bananas are exposed to air, this method significantly slows down the enzymatic browning process. The freshness of the bananas is crucial, as fresher bananas are less prone to rapid browning compared to older, more ripened ones.

Immediate preparation requires careful planning and timing. It is advisable to have all other components of the pie, such as the crust and cream, fully prepared and ready. Once these elements are set, the bananas can be quickly sliced and arranged in the pie. This swift transition from peeling to incorporation into the pie helps maintain the bananas’ vibrant yellow hue, enhancing the visual appeal of the dessert.

This approach not only preserves the aesthetic quality of the banana cream pie but also ensures that the texture and flavor of the bananas are at their peak. Freshly sliced bananas offer a firm yet tender bite, a contrast to the creamy components of the pie, creating a delightful sensory experience. By implementing immediate preparation, bakers can significantly improve the overall quality and presentation of their banana cream pies.

Using Citrus Juices

A popular and effective method to prevent bananas from browning in a banana cream pie is the use of citrus juices. The key lies in the natural acidity of citrus fruits like lemon, orange, and pineapple, which are known to slow down the enzymatic browning process. This method not only preserves the fresh, appealing color of the bananas but also adds a subtle zest to the overall flavor profile of the pie.

Lemon juice is the most commonly used citrus for this purpose. Its high acid content makes it particularly effective in inhibiting the oxidation process. To apply, gently brush a thin layer of freshly squeezed lemon juice over the sliced bananas. This creates a protective barrier between the banana’s flesh and the air, significantly reducing browning. The tartness of the lemon can also complement the sweetness of the bananas, adding a refreshing twist to the pie.

Orange juice offers a sweeter alternative to lemon juice, with a less pronounced acidic taste. Its application is similar – a light brushing or spritzing over the banana slices. The natural sugars in orange juice can enhance the sweetness of the bananas, making it a preferred choice for those who favor a sweeter dessert.

Pineapple juice is another excellent option, known for its enzymatic properties that can further contribute to preserving the bananas’ color and texture. Like with lemon and orange juices, a light application is sufficient to coat the banana slices, providing the necessary protection against browning.

When using citrus juices, it’s important to strike a balance between preventing browning and maintaining the pie’s intended flavor. Overuse of any citrus juice can overpower the delicate flavor of the bananas and the creamy components of the pie. Therefore, a light and even application is crucial. This method not only extends the visual appeal of the banana cream pie but also introduces an additional layer of flavor, subtly enhancing the overall taste experience.

Alternative Methods

Beyond the use of citrus juices, there are several alternative methods to prevent bananas from browning in a banana cream pie, each offering its unique approach to tackling this culinary challenge. These methods focus on creating barriers against oxidation or altering the environment around the banana slices to slow down the browning process.

One innovative technique involves using honey mixed with water. By diluting honey in a bit of water and gently brushing it onto the banana slices, a thin protective layer is formed. This layer not only shields the bananas from excessive air exposure but also imparts a subtle sweetness, complementing the natural flavor of the bananas. The viscosity of honey helps in evenly coating the slices, ensuring consistent protection.

Layering the banana slices between pastry cream is another effective strategy. This method involves placing a layer of pastry cream both below and above the banana slices within the pie. The cream acts as a physical barrier, limiting the bananas’ exposure to air and thus reducing oxidation. Additionally, the creamy texture of the pastry cream adds to the overall richness of the pie, while effectively preserving the bananas’ texture and color.

Another alternative is the use of vacuum-sealed containers for storing sliced bananas before their use in the pie. By removing air from the environment, this method significantly slows down the enzymatic browning process. While this technique requires additional equipment, it is highly effective, especially when preparing the pie components in advance.

For those seeking a more natural approach, ascorbic acid powder, a form of vitamin C, can be dissolved in water and used to coat the banana slices. This method not only prevents browning but also adds nutritional value to the pie. The key is to use a minimal amount to avoid altering the pie’s flavor.

Each of these alternative methods offers a unique solution to the browning problem, allowing bakers to choose based on their preferences and the resources available. By employing these techniques, the visual appeal and taste of the banana cream pie can be significantly enhanced, ensuring a delightful dessert experience.

Storage and Shelf Life

Proper storage plays a crucial role in extending the shelf life of a banana cream pie while maintaining its quality. The key to preserving this dessert lies in understanding the delicate balance between temperature and humidity. Ideally, a banana cream pie should be stored in the refrigerator, as the cool temperature slows down the enzymatic reactions that cause browning and spoilage.

When refrigerating, it’s important to cover the pie, either with a pie keeper or a loose covering of plastic wrap. This prevents the pie from absorbing any odors from the refrigerator and also maintains optimal humidity levels around the pie. However, care should be taken to ensure that the covering is not too tight, as this can lead to condensation, which may make the crust soggy and affect the texture of the pie.

In terms of shelf life, a freshly made banana cream pie is best enjoyed within the first 24 to 48 hours. This timeframe ensures that the bananas and the cream are at their peak in terms of flavor and texture. While the pie can be kept for up to three days in the refrigerator, it’s important to note that the quality may begin to diminish, with the bananas potentially turning brown and the crust losing its crispness.

To sum up, proper refrigeration and careful covering are essential for extending the shelf life of a banana cream pie, ensuring that each slice is as enjoyable as the first.

Advanced Preservation Techniques

For those looking to elevate their banana cream pie game, advanced preservation techniques can be the key to achieving longer-lasting freshness and visual appeal. These methods delve into more sophisticated approaches, combining culinary art with scientific principles.

One advanced technique involves the use of antioxidant solutions. These solutions, often containing ascorbic acid or calcium ascorbate, can be lightly brushed onto the banana slices. They work by providing a potent barrier against oxidation, far more effective than simple citrus juices. This method is particularly favored in professional baking settings where maintaining the pie’s appearance for an extended period is crucial.

Another innovative approach is the use of modified atmosphere packaging (MAP). This technique, commonly used in the food industry, involves altering the composition of gases in the packaging environment. By reducing the oxygen levels and increasing other gases like nitrogen or carbon dioxide, the rate of enzymatic browning is significantly slowed down. While this method requires specialized equipment, it’s incredibly effective for pies that need to be stored or transported over longer durations.

Vacuum sealing is also a viable option for preserving pre-sliced bananas. By removing air from the packaging, the process of oxidation is greatly reduced. This method is particularly useful when preparing ingredients in advance, ensuring that the bananas remain fresh until they are used in the pie.

For home bakers, a more accessible technique is the use of fruit-fresh produce protectors. These products, available in most grocery stores, contain natural antioxidants that help preserve the color and texture of fresh-cut fruits. A light sprinkle on the banana slices before assembling the pie can work wonders in extending their freshness.


Q1: Why do bananas in banana cream pie turn brown?

Bananas turn brown in a banana cream pie due to a natural enzymatic reaction. When bananas are exposed to air, an enzyme called polyphenol oxidase reacts with oxygen, leading to the formation of melanin, which gives the brown color. This process is accelerated when bananas are cut, as it increases the surface area exposed to air.

Q2: How can I prevent bananas from browning in my pie?

To prevent browning, you can use methods like brushing the banana slices with citrus juices such as lemon, orange, or pineapple juice. These juices contain acids that slow down the enzymatic reaction. Alternatively, you can coat the slices with a mixture of honey and water, or layer them with pastry cream to minimize air exposure.

Q3: Can I make banana cream pie in advance?

Yes, you can make banana cream pie in advance, but it’s best consumed within 24 to 48 hours. Store it in the refrigerator, covered loosely with plastic wrap or a pie keeper. This helps maintain the texture and flavor of the pie while preventing the bananas from browning quickly.


In conclusion, crafting the perfect banana cream pie is an art that combines culinary skill with a touch of science. From understanding the history of this beloved dessert to mastering the techniques to prevent banana browning, each step plays a crucial role in creating a pie that is as delightful to look at as it is to eat. The key to success lies in the careful selection of ingredients, precise timing in preparation, and the implementation of effective preservation methods.

Whether you’re a home baker or a professional chef, the insights shared in this article provide valuable guidance for making a banana cream pie that stands out. The use of citrus juices, alternative methods like honey-water coating, and advanced preservation techniques ensure that your pie remains fresh and visually appealing. Proper storage and understanding the shelf life are essential to maintain the quality of your dessert.

Remember, the beauty of banana cream pie lies not just in its taste but also in its presentation. By following these tips and techniques, you can create a banana cream pie that is sure to impress, making it a memorable treat for any occasion.


Leave a comment